What exactly is the difference between a gig bag, a quality gig bag, and a soft case? Here is a quick general rundown:
Gig bags. Most often found with entry level instruments. These floppy, unstructured bags are little more than fancy dust covers-- with handles. These entry level bags are sometimes included with mid-range import instruments such as Squire and Mexican made Fender's. The bags can be found sold separately for around $40, and are better than having nothing at all.
Quality gig bags. This is by no means an all-inclusive definition, but there are a few generally accepted criteria for a "quality" bag. First it should offer padding that surrounds all sides of the instrument, and have some sort of neck support. Bags in this category when not housing an instrument should have very little "floppiness" about them and have at least 1/2 inch padding.
Quality gig bags are a great choice for those who don't travel a lot with their instrument and want a reasonable level of protection should the propped up instrument be knocked over accidentally. These are great for people who use public transportation as the bags are much easier than traditional cases to carry in crowed areas and still offer protection from bumps and bangs.
Some of the more popular offerings are the Mono Vertigo (shown), Mono M80, and gator's ProGo series. These typically cost between $150 - $200.
Carvin's soft case supporting a 30-lb bass amplifier without a bass inside |
Jeff Kiesel drop testing his soft case |
Now that I've got the definitions out of the way, why do I like quality gig bags, and soft cases better than traditional wooden cases? Simple-- they work best for me. Subjectivity is necessary when searching for your own bag/case solution-- only you know what will work best for you-- though there remains room for objective reasoning.
Take shock forces for instance. The typical wooden case utilizes very little interior padding, with the neck being supported just below the headstock. So dropping a hard case on concrete several feet from the ground will likely jar the locks open (depending on design) and transmit the force of the shock directly to the instrument.
Many soft cases have thick padding that can absorb and displace the shock from a drop. Granted, soft cases are not fool-proof solutions, but they do improve the odds of your instrument surviving the shock of a drop.
So exactly what did I select to replace the generic G&G case that came with my new Plum Crazy G&L? I'll cover that in my next post, so 'till then...
Stay tuned & in tune!~